Welcome, Guest. Please
Login
Home
Help
Search
Login
FAQ
Radified
Ghost.Classic
Ghost.New
Bootable CD
Blog
Radified Community Forums
›
Rad Community Technical Discussion Boards (Computer Hardware + PC Software)
›
PC Hardware + Software (except Cloning programs)
› Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
(Moderators: Rad, Christer, NightOwl, Pleonasm, MrMagoo, El_Pescador)
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
Pages:
1
2
3
Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender? (Read 71523 times)
Dan Goodell
Special Guest
Offline
Posts: 552
N California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #15 -
May 23
rd
, 2008 at 5:38am
"if you need to do fine measurement to tell the difference that'd be a negative result in my book"
Yes, I would agree. I've told people that if their laptop already has 'g', then spending money to replace it with 'n' won't do any good unless they have a 'n' base station. So I wanted to make sure I haven't been misadvising them.
But I've also been telling them that replacing a 'g' base station with 'n' won't make any difference unless they also replace the laptop adapter with 'n'. Based on your comments above, I'll have to modify that somewhat.
IP Logged
Brian
Demigod
Offline
Posts: 6345
NSW, Australia
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #16 -
May 26
th
, 2008 at 4:55pm
I'm using a Linksys WAG54G. Can I use my old Linksys WRT54GS, with DHCP disabled, as a repeater and extend my range?
IP Logged
Rad
Radministrator
Offline
Sufferin' succotash
Posts: 4090
Newport Beach, California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #17 -
May 27
th
, 2008 at 9:43pm
Magoo sent me a Wireless Range Expander he had laying around, not using. It arrived today. Linksys WRE54G. At first I thought it might have trouble, cuz the house Wireless unit = 2Wire. But it works fine. Basically plug it in and load install CD. Have to have a connection to source wireless in order for WRE54G to sync-up.
I put it ~half way between me and the source router. Signal boosted from low/dropping to good. Definitely faster.
Thanks Magoo. Karma to you.
This thing was still in the shrinkwarp .. never opened. I love you, man.
IP Logged
Dan Goodell
Special Guest
Offline
Posts: 552
N California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #18 -
May 28
th
, 2008 at 7:58am
"Can I use my old Linksys WRT54GS, with DHCP disabled, as a repeater and extend my range?"
Probably, but it might depend on how old your "old Linksys WRT54GS" is. GS versions 5.0 and later have crippled the amount of flash memory, so the only dd-wrt version you can use is the stripped-down "micro" version. Earlier GS versions could use any dd-wrt. I haven't used the micro version, so can't confirm what's in the feature set.
I've become familiar enough with the choices, but for a newcomer the plethora of download choices is a serious source of confusion. First, there's the main versions (2.2, 2.3, 2.4, etc.), then there's the mid-version betas and release candidates (rc2, rc7, etc.), then there's the feature set variations (standard, mini, micro, mega, voip, vpn), and finally there may be different builds for different hardware (Asus, Belkin, Linksys, Dell, etc., and "generic").
(Tip: the "Linksys" builds are only if you're using a stand-alone tftp uploader; if you're upgrading via the router's web interface, use the "generic" build.)
Documentation isn't bad, but the Wiki idea doesn't lend itself well to coherent organization, making info sometimes hard to find or follow. To cut through some of the confusion, here's some quick links:
Linksys router version numbers
dd-wrt features
feature set variations
specific instructions for WRT54GS
Assuming you're not restricted to the "micro" version type, I recommend:
download: dd-wrt.v24_mini_generic.bin
download: dd-wrt.v24_std_generic.bin
reset the GS to factory defaults
isolate your computer and GS from your existing LAN:
disable your computer's wireless adapter
set computer to static IP 192.168.1.10
connect ethernet cable from router to computer
using the GS's web interface, flash the mini_generic version
reboot
using the GS's web interface, flash the std_generic version
configure GS as repeater
See the
dd-wrt tutorials
for lots of neat options that can keep a geek happy for months. In particular, I like static dhcp (which comes in handy setting up network printers, or when configuring port forwarding to specific machines), and pptp vpn (which allows me, without special software or special vpn routers, to vpn into my LAN when I'm away from home).
IP Logged
Amish.
Technoluster
Offline
Dude! (Rad in SeaMonkey)
Posts: 104
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #19 -
May 28
th
, 2008 at 2:36pm
Must say .. beautifully-formatted post. Bullets. Paragraphs. Links. Clean.
IP Logged
TheShadow
Kahuna
Offline
Old Ghost user!
Posts: 613
Florida, USA
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #20 -
Jun 3
rd
, 2008 at 2:07pm
For those people using Linksys wireless routers, the ones with dual antennas, Radio Shack sells High Gain antennas for them.
The replacement antennas are at least twice as long as the original ones and should give extended range.
I'm considering investing in a pair. I'd like to link my neighbor to my system and their computer is about 200' away.
just a thought,
The Shadow
IP Logged
Dan Goodell
Special Guest
Offline
Posts: 552
N California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #21 -
Jun 4
th
, 2008 at 7:22pm
"Radio Shack sells High Gain antennas for them. [...] I'm considering investing in a pair. I'd like to link my neighbor to my system and their computer is about 200' away."
Shadow, if you do that, I hope you'll share your assessment of how well it works.
Or if anyone has tried a directional antenna (like
this Hawking example
) with a run-of-the-mill consumer-grade router, I'd like to hear about that, too. I'm curious what inexpensive options are available to the ordinary home user who just wants a little more range.
IP Logged
MrMagoo
Übermensch
Offline
Resident Linux Guru
Posts: 1026
Phoenix, AZ (USA)
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #22 -
Jun 4
th
, 2008 at 8:57pm
TheShadow wrote
on Jun 3
rd
, 2008 at 2:07pm:
For those people using Linksys wireless routers, the ones with dual antennas, Radio Shack sells High Gain antennas for them.
My only problem with the Hi-gain antennas is that they usually cost as much as a repeater or another router would. It might be a good idea if you have a really expensive 802.11N router, but for the cheaper routers it seems to make more fiscal sense to buy a repeater.
IP Logged
Brian
Demigod
Offline
Posts: 6345
NSW, Australia
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #23 -
Jun 4
th
, 2008 at 11:37pm
Dan,
I'm out of town and have just noticed your post. Thanks. I'll work on it in a few days time.
IP Logged
Dan Goodell
Special Guest
Offline
Posts: 552
N California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #24 -
Jun 5
th
, 2008 at 7:32am
"My only problem with the Hi-gain antennas is that they usually cost as much as a repeater or another router would."
That's a good point, and worth keeping in mind.
But don't forget you need to have a power outlet available. If The Shadow only has outside space between him and the neighbor, there wouldn't be a place to plug in a router/repeater.
Between my parents' house and their neighbors, it was convenient that my parents' garage was appx halfway between the two, so it was natural to stick a repeater in the garage to relay the signal from the neighbors. And also more neighborly than going over and changing their antenna.
IP Logged
LoTGoD
Radmeister
Offline
Black eyes...broken fingers
Posts: 53
Ohio
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #25 -
Jun 5
th
, 2008 at 8:55am
Looks like these are only $9.99. Not too shabby if they work...
http://www.radioshack.com/family/index.jsp?categoryId=2032382&cp=2032061.2032365...
IP Logged
John.
Übermensch
Offline
Posts: 2072
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #26 -
Jun 5
th
, 2008 at 9:32am
There's an interesting article in the July 2008 issue of Maximum PC magazine on upgrading the Linksys WRT54G router with other firmware, specifically the Tomato firmware. Also some performance and feature enhancements.
http://www.maximumpc.com/article/hack_your_hardware?page=0%2C3
http://www.polarcloud.com/tomato
Ghost4me Ghost 9, 10, 12, 14, 15. Windows XP, Vista, Windows 7
IP Logged
Rad
Radministrator
Offline
Sufferin' succotash
Posts: 4090
Newport Beach, California
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #27 -
Jun 5
th
, 2008 at 7:28pm
A little problem I had was that another laptop in the main house COULD NOT SEE the repeater. I'm guessing this was cuz the router ("gateway" they say this is called) is 2wire, while the PCMCIA card in the other laptop is also 2wire, while the extender is Linksys. So the two 2wire items connect fine, but the 2wire laptop cannot seee the Linksys extender. (After loading install CD, it says "No Linksys extender can be found" .. while sitting right next to it).
And then the Linksys extender was interfereing with the connection between the 2wire (PCMCIA) laptop and 2wire router/gateway. Soon as you unplug the Linksys, the laptop would then immediately see (connect to) the router/gateway.
Sorta fixed this by moving the extender to a different room, which was previously sitting right next to 2wire laptop.
Also the AT&T ppl kinda screwed up by putting the router/gateway on firplace mantel (which contains metal flue), which was a bad place to put it. They came out a couple days ago and moved it away from and on the OTHER SIDE of the fireplace, so the firplace is now NOT BETWEEN router/gateway and laptops. That seemed to help a lot. Before, I think the metal flue was bouncing the signal A-WAY from the direction where it was needed
IP Logged
Brian
Demigod
Offline
Posts: 6345
NSW, Australia
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #28 -
Jun 6
th
, 2008 at 2:27am
Dan and John,
My old Linksys router, WRT54GS, was ver 1.0 so I flashed dd-wrt.v24-9517_VINT_std.bin. I chose Repeater mode and entered my WPA number but I must be omitting something as the signal strength and range of the signal is unchanged whether the WRT54GS is on or off.
Anything obvious here?
IP Logged
Brian
Demigod
Offline
Posts: 6345
NSW, Australia
Back to top
Re: Wireless Repeater vs Range Extender?
Reply #29 -
Jun 7
th
, 2008 at 4:29am
I followed the tutorials and setup the WRT54GS for wireless bridge mode, then repeater bridge mode. I can't detect any better range or signal at the "periphery" of my network.
PS... I finally got it working. I'm not sure yet about extended range but signal strength in marginal areas has been improved significantly.
IP Logged
Pages:
1
2
3
‹
Previous Topic
|
Next Topic
›
« Home
‹ Board
Top of this page
Forum Jump »
Home
» 10 most recent Posts
» 10 most recent Topics
Rad Community Technical Discussion Boards (Computer Hardware + PC Software)
- Norton Ghost 15, 14, 12, 10, 9, + Norton Save + Restore (NS+R)
- Norton Ghost 2003, Ghost v8.x + Ghost Solution Suite (GSS) Discussion Board
- Cloning Programs (Except Norton Ghost)
- NightOwl's Bootable CD/DVD
- PC Hardware + Software (except Cloning programs) ««
Rad Community Non-Technical Discussion Boards
- The Water Cooler
- YaBB Forum Software + Rad Web Site
Radified Community Forums
» Powered by
YaBB 2.4
!
YaBB
© 2000-2009. All Rights Reserved.